However, sometimes he can be a little immature, such as in "Toby's Untrue Achoo!" when he faked being sick in order to get some attention. In "Toby the Cowsitter", he offers to watch a group of cows and then leaves to get milkshakes, suggesting he's also forgetful.
He's also very innocent, rarely ever understanding the times he's being swindled or even insulted, such as in "Peck Takes It Back", where Peck calls him a pinecone. Instead, Toby goes out to find an actual pinecone for Peck because he believes he didn't know what they looked like. He doesn't seem to hold grudges or get angry easily, either, even after his skills are criticized in "Horsehoe Peck". In "Toby Braves the Bully" he is against telling Callie and Peck about his bully because he thinks it would make him a tattletale.
Toby is usually very cheerful and he loves to dance. He is also shown to love popcorn in several episodes, as well as milkshakes.
Toby in The Cat Who Tamed the West.
Toby and Peck in The Cat Who Tamed the West.
Toby delivering mail in Toby Braves the Bully.
Toby and Peck in Peck's Trail Mix Mix-Up.
Toby and friends in the Season 2 intro.
Toby is hurt by Peck's bragging.
Toby grows a desert flower on his nose.
Trying to fix Callie's quilt in Peck and Toby's Big Yarn.