Timon and Pumbaa indulge in a variety of bugs in a dish marked "Baby". Pumbaa compliments his pal's ability to find bugs (since he was unable to find any. Soon, however, a mother eagle snatches up Timon and accuses him of taking her baby's food. While she was teaching Baby Earl to fly, she claims Timon swiped the grubs. He says she needs proof, but she produces plenty of proof (such as a footprint, witnesses, his wallet, and a security photo. The eagle and Pumbaa pity Timon into babysitting Earl while the mother flies to retrieve more bugs.
Back at the eagle nest, the mother threatens to hurt Timon if anything bad happens to Baby Earl. As soon as the mother eagle leaves, Timon leaves the nest, but Pumbaa reminds him that he has to play a game with Earl, read to him, and tuck him in for a nap. Timon quickly plays a game of cards, reads "The Three Bears", and puts Earl to bed. He tries to leave, but Pumbaa is not satisfied with Timon's work. They turn around to look at the chick, who is trying to jump over the edge of the nest. The caregivers catch him each of the three times he jumps.
Pumbaa points out that the duo will need to actually stay and babysit, but Timon says he will use reverse psychology to convince the bird to stay. He tells Earl to leap out of the nest, hoping for the opposite, but the baby takes him seriously and jumps. They quickly chase after him to keep him safe. They bridge a gap in the path to keep him from falling, which results in them falling. Earl climbs to the end of a log, which the two swing around, but they can't avoid falling. When the cliff comes to an end, they quickly construct a bridge, but they are flattened by a large truck.
Earl finally makes his way back to the nest and has no scratch on him. He plummets again from the nest, while Timon expects that he will begin flying before he hits the ground.
He crashes into the ground just before the mother eagle returns, expecting to see her child. Pumbaa causes her to be infuriated by telling her the truth, but soon Earl flies back up to his mommy. She asks how she'll be able to repay Timon and Pumbaa. The two are compensated by being fed more delicious grubs.
The title of this episode is a play on the title of Harper Lee's novel, "To Kill a Mockingbird."