FANDOM


  • So, here comes yet another question, which movie do you consider to be the best, Frozen or The Godfather? Considering The Godfather has been called "the greatest movie ever made" (along with a few other pictures), it should play in the big leagues of Disney-classics such as Frozen. Though I disagree. For me, of course it's Frozen, that movie is a real masterpiece!

    Frozen or The Godfather?
     
    18
     
    9
     

    The poll was created at 12:58 on May 8, 2014, and so far 27 people voted.
      Loading editor
    • Call me uncultured, but I've never seen the latter. It'd be wrong for me to vote if I haven't experienced both films so unfortunately, I can't really provide any commentary on this matter :/

        Loading editor
    • Dragonboy6491 wrote:
      Call me uncultured, but I've never seen the latter. It'd be wrong for me to vote if I haven't experienced both films so unfortunately, I can't really provide any commentary on this matter :/

      Indeed, that's really wise, and I actually had the same thoughts earlier, so basically what I did was I decided to see the movie. Though, for me, it didn't really deliver the way Frozen did.

        Loading editor
    • Hmm perhaps I'll check it out and see how it compares. I don't think I'll prefer it over Frozen seeing as it is now literally my definition of the perfect movie, but who knows? I might be pleasantly surprised xD.

        Loading editor
    • I am stunned at how someone can even prefer The Godfather over Frozen.

        Loading editor
    • Frozen is the best film I have ever seen. Way better than The Godfather.

      Frozen or The Godfather?
       
      18
       
      9
       

      The poll was created at 12:58 on May 8, 2014, and so far 27 people voted.

      </div>

        Loading editor
    • QElsa938 wrote:
      Frozen is the best film I have ever seen. Way better than The Godfather.
      Frozen or The Godfather?
       
      18
       
      9
       

      The poll was created at 12:58 on May 8, 2014, and so far 27 people voted.

      </div>

      That sounds more right, I can definetely agree on that!

        Loading editor
    • There really is no comparison between the two. I mean that quite literally.

        Loading editor
    • I'm still baffled at the current results of this poll, come on people!

        Loading editor
    • Activity?

        Loading editor
    • This is crazy!

        Loading editor
    • Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!

      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.

        Loading editor
    • Varg2000
      Varg2000 removed this reply because:
      Unecessary and insulting.
      20:16, August 18, 2014
      This reply has been removed
    • Varg2000 wrote:

      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!

      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.

      No that your comparing the godfather to Frozen. There to different to compare.

        Loading editor
    • Thedisneymillionare wrote:

      Varg2000 wrote:



      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!
      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.
      No that your comparing the godfather to Frozen. There to different to compare.

      I guess it varries from person to person. Although I thought Frozen was a much greater experience. And I'm not merely comparing contents, I'm comparing personal experiences and worldwide impacts aswell. All have to be considered. Did The Godfather really give you such a great experience that you would watch it again and again and recommend it to your family, kids, friends and other people etc.? And do you think it would have a greater impact among these people than Frozen would have? Those are important questions to ask. Especially looking at how the world looks today, comparing the impact Frozen has had on the whole world to the impact of The Godfather. I don't know about you, but I'd say The Godfather is very overrated and not much different from other films with the same theme and genre. But yes, at the end of the day, it cannot really be compared to the truly greatest films out there, like Frozen, I mean it stands no chance against that Disney Classic. Honestly.

        Loading editor
    • Varg2000 wrote:

      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!

      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.

      > Implying that Frozen is better than The Godfather?

        Loading editor
    • ResonX wrote:

      Varg2000 wrote:


      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!
      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.
      > Implying that Frozen is better than The Godfather?

      Well, it's my opinion, so logically it would be implied, eh? Got a problem with differing personal opinions? And really, I don't "imply" that it's better than The Godfather, I'm clearly stating it. Really, I do not see what would be so remarkable about that film, and especially what would make it better than Frozen (of all films) and deserving of the title of "the greatest movie ever" when it shows no such impact or contents. It has nothing of the masterpiece-material that Frozen has (not to mention my criteria for "the greatest movie ever" are more serious and requires that the movie can be watched, enjoyed and learned from by practically everyone, regardless of age, gender or location; it can't be limited to generally one or few groups; and its impact has to be worldwide and demonstrable), and its impact wasn't even close to that of Frozen. In my experience, The Godfather is seriously heavily overrated and not much different from other similar (and even awful) films.

        Loading editor
    • I don't even think there's any comparison. Godfather's a classic.


      That's like comparing Robocop with Jaws.

        Loading editor
    • This list is really biassed.  Godfather is a fantastic movie on its own, but a movie about an Itallian mafia family shouldn't be compared to an animated musical about a young woman who sets off an eternal winter. With that said, I often like to refer to Toy Story as "The Godfather of Animated Movies."  Not because Toy Story is better than Godfather, but because like how Godfather changed mainstream cinema, Toy Story changed mainstream animation.  And just on a side not, did you ever even see The Godfather? I wouldn't call something I've never seen before overrated if I haven't seen it before.

        Loading editor
    • Varg2000 wrote:
      ResonX wrote:

      Varg2000 wrote:


      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!
      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.
      > Implying that Frozen is better than The Godfather?
      Well, it's my opinion, so logically it would be implied, eh? Got a problem with differing personal opinions? And really, I don't "imply" that it's better than The Godfather, I'm clearly stating it. Really, I do not see what would be so remarkable about that film, and especially what would make it better than Frozen (of all films) and deserving of the title of "the greatest movie ever" when it shows no such impact or contents. It has nothing of the masterpiece-material that Frozen has (not to mention my criteria for "the greatest movie ever" are more serious and requires that the movie can be watched, enjoyed and learned from by practically everyone, regardless of age, gender or location; it can't be limited to generally one or few groups; and its impact has to be worldwide and demonstrable), and its impact wasn't even close to that of Frozen. In my experience, The Godfather is seriously heavily overrated and not much different from other similar (and even awful) films.

      Just because you find Frozen to be one of the greatest movies ever doesn't mean everyone else does, like how I don't really find Frozen to be that great of a movie.

        Loading editor
    • DonyarktheKungFuMinion wrote:
      This list is really biassed.  Godfather is a fantastic movie on its own, but a movie about an Itallian mafia family shouldn't be compared to an animated musical about a young woman who sets off an eternal winter. With that said, I often like to refer to Toy Story as "The Godfather of Animated Movies."  Not because Toy Story is better than Godfather, but because like how Godfather changed mainstream cinema, Toy Story changed mainstream animation.  And just on a side not, did you ever even see The Godfather? I wouldn't call something I've never seen before overrated if I haven't seen it before.

      As I said, it's like comparing Robocop with Jaws.

        Loading editor
    • Cloverfield monster wrote:
      I don't even think there's any comparison. Godfather's a classic.


      That's like comparing Robocop with Jaws.

      The Godfather may be a classic (for some mysterious reason), but so is Frozen. One can't really deny that. Also, do remember that comparing these films should be based upon your personal experience of each film, deciding which film gave you the best experience, and thus which film is the best in your opinion.

        Loading editor
    • DonyarktheKungFuMinion wrote:
      This list is really biassed.  Godfather is a fantastic movie on its own, but a movie about an Itallian mafia family shouldn't be compared to an animated musical about a young woman who sets off an eternal winter. With that said, I often like to refer to Toy Story as "The Godfather of Animated Movies."  Not because Toy Story is better than Godfather, but because like how Godfather changed mainstream cinema, Toy Story changed mainstream animation.  And just on a side not, did you ever even see The Godfather? I wouldn't call something I've never seen before overrated if I haven't seen it before.

      Biased it may be, but it doesn't matter. I do not see what is supposedly so "fantastic" (this word sounds a bit exaggerated) about The Godfather (of all films!). I say as I did in a previous reply; while comparing these films one should consider which film gave you the greatest experience, and thus that should logically decide which film was the best in your personal opinion. How exactly did The Godfather "change mainstream cinema"? What do you really mean by this? And yes, I have actually seen The Godfather (which was one of my worst cinematic experiences of my life, and I'm still wondering why people would even care to praise this awful film to such ridiculous heights as have been done). I wouldn't even try to comment on a movie I've never seen before, and thus we'd never have this conversation.

        Loading editor
    • DonyarktheKungFuMinion wrote:
      Varg2000 wrote:
      ResonX wrote:

      Varg2000 wrote:



      Thedisneymillionare wrote:
      This is crazy!
      I know right? But some people actually mean to say The Godfather is the greatest (and thus better than Frozen) movie ever made, and that is indeed insane.
      > Implying that Frozen is better than The Godfather?
      Well, it's my opinion, so logically it would be implied, eh? Got a problem with differing personal opinions? And really, I don't "imply" that it's better than The Godfather, I'm clearly stating it. Really, I do not see what would be so remarkable about that film, and especially what would make it better than Frozen (of all films) and deserving of the title of "the greatest movie ever" when it shows no such impact or contents. It has nothing of the masterpiece-material that Frozen has (not to mention my criteria for "the greatest movie ever" are more serious and requires that the movie can be watched, enjoyed and learned from by practically everyone, regardless of age, gender or location; it can't be limited to generally one or few groups; and its impact has to be worldwide and demonstrable), and its impact wasn't even close to that of Frozen. In my experience, The Godfather is seriously heavily overrated and not much different from other similar (and even awful) films.
      Just because you find Frozen to be one of the greatest movies ever doesn't mean everyone else does, like how I don't really find Frozen to be that great of a movie.

      I never said that either, I'm just sharing my personal experience and cultural observations. Everyone are entitled to their own personal opinions, that means you have all the rights to disagree with my view, but I will say that (as can be observed) a truly considerable amount of people worldwide shares a similar viewpoint as the one I previously expressed. It sounds like you took my reply as a bit offensive though, but please don't. Just, don't take it too hard. Learn to live with it.

        Loading editor
    • A FANDOM user
        Loading editor
Give Kudos to this message
You've given this message Kudos!
See who gave Kudos to this message