The next time Sexton is seen, he is playing on an organ, using his hands and feet. He complains to Friar Tuck that nobody is coming. As his wife gives Friar Tuck their last farthing, and he blesses them both, Sexton remarks that they were saving it for a rainy day. As the Sheriff of Nottingham enters, he rudely asks what he wants, only to be shushed by his wife. He is then shown in the doorway, watching the Sheriff and Friar Tuck fight, cheering for the latter, only to see the former arrest him thanks to Trigger. He then comforts his wife who is devastated at the latter being arrested for high treason to the crown.
He and Little Sister are not seen again until Robin Hood and Maid Marian are getting married, where the two are throwing rice after King Richard finally returns, reclaiming his throne from his brother and has him, Sir Hiss and the Sheriff of Nottingham arrested for their crimes.