Old Tim is the name of the Ice Moose, the equivalent of Kris Kringle/Saint Nicholas/Santa Claus within the world of PB&J Otter. It is believed by some that if, on Hoohaw Hoo Eve, you turn around three times, make Ice Moose antlers, go "honk honk honk" and then make a wish on the star of Hoohaw Hoo, then Old Tim and his Sugarplum Ferrets (the equivalents of Santa's reindeer) will grant it. In "The Ice Moose", PB&J and the others put on a pageant about Old Tim. Peanut, Butter, Jelly and most of their friends believe that Old Tim is real, though Flick, disappointed at not receiving the flashy presents he wanted, has stopped believing (if he ever truly believed at all). Flick's disbelief is tested when he meets a young mouse who wishes on the Ice Moose to fly. He receives a visit from Old Tim in a dream. Additionally, at the end of "The Ice Moose", Old Tim and his Sugarplum Ferrets are shown driving off in a sleighboat. Tim exclaims "Happy Hoohaw to all and to all a hawhoo!" in a nod to the final line from the classic Christmas poem "Twas the Night Before Christmas" (or "A Visit from Saint Nicholas"). Butter refers to him as "Moo-Moo".
Season One:Oodelay-O • Noodle Dance • Bye, Bye PB&J • Pickin' Babbleberries • Secret Hidden Treasure • Squeezin' and a-Wheezin' • Come On In • Close Your Eyes • Gorilla Go Away • Get Those Bubbles • Jumpy's Themes • Fiddlin' Funs • What You Need • Put on Your Best Face • Good Clean Fun • The Best Party Ever • Just Not Cool/Just Too Hot • Blowing Bubbles • Pop, Pop, Pop • Jump Down on the Truth • Hooray for Captain Peanut • Everybody Wants to Be a Soap Box Racer • Look at Me • On the Shores of Lake Hoohaw • Otters Three • Shipshape • Otters in the Wild • Catch a Bunch of Bass • We Hope You Enjoyed the Show
Season Two: Do the Waddle • P-O-O-D-L-E • Nearly Dancing • Opal's Lullaby • Hoohawan Birthday Song • Who Needs Toys? • Whammy Clammy • Glasses Boy • Down in Old Hoohaw • PB&J's Mother's Day Song • I'm So Strong • Come Back • Hoo-Haw, Hoo-Haw • Anything Can Happen • Finders Keepers, Losers Weepers • Scrub-a Dub-a • El Dorado • Everybody Wins • PB&J's Good Night Song • The Woof-Woof Song • The Goodnight-Woof-Woof Mashup • Save Our Tree • John Jacob Jingle-Otter Breath • Bubble-O Popple-O • Super Socks • We Are Noodle-Matic Puppets • Welcome to Our Toys • Welcome to Our Fun • It Works Both Ways • When I'm in My Shoes • We're Only Just Kids • Gotta Find Our Friend • Practice Makes Perfect • Sisters and Brothers • At the Fair • Sherlock Otters • Who's Your Buddy? • Let the Fun Begin! • We Want Something Different • Flying • An Oodely-Doodely Day • Follow Your Nose • Hoohaw Hoo • The Bankie Song • Zip-Zap-Zoom! • Tippecanoe and Tickle Me Too • Treasure Magnifico • There Aren't Any Monsters • My Lucky Mirror • A Never-Ending Song • 'Til You're Better Again • Catching Lightning Bugs • Watching Lightning Bugs • Otter Cafe • Thanks to Peanut Otter • Slow 'n' Steady • Friends • We're On Our Own • Go Slow, You Know Season Three: Halloween • Making Fun • One, Two, Three (Playing Together) • Givin' Dad a Hand • Friends and Neighbors • Biggest Little Thing • Talkin' Bout Hoohaw Lake • From Our Heart • Ballad of Johnny Pompalope • Teamwork • When are We Gonna Get There? • Laugh it Out! • Worth the Wait (Patience) • Imaginings • Munchy is Whistling • Big, Bad Billy the Duck • Good Old Billy the Duck • A Helping Partnership • Speak Your Feelings Out • What Makes You Shine • The Come Back Mama Song • I Love My Life • The Clean-up Song (Everything in its Place) • Have Fun • The Great Outdoors • Gotta Keep Thinking, Gotta Keep Hoping • A Simple Hat • I Love a Good Book! (The Reading Song) • Oodelee, Oodelay (The Hoohawan Lullaby) • A Watchbird is Watching • My Official Soccer Team Hat • Sharing Babbleberries • I Might Just Find Something New Today • I Wish I Was Home • No Big Deal • Little Friend • Our New, Old Friend • Time for a Little TLC • We'll Laugh Together • Gonna Make the Giggle Melons Grow • Make it Last • Try, Try Again • All Together We Can Build It (Sandcastle Song) • Hope Will Carry Us Through • Nothing Lasts Forever • Before You Go • We Always Win! • All By Myself • We're Best Friends • Redolfo, Redolfo • Wedding in Hoohaw • PB&J's Wedding Dedication Song • Big Beaver Now • Don't Judge a Book By its Cover • You Just Can't Hide your Heart • New Friends, Life's Sweet Surprise • Nothing to Do in Lake Hoohaw • It's Gonna Be Great • No Place We'd Rather Be