Ben and Mal are still dancing together when Jay and Carlos finally arrive at the party very late. Mal and the girls ask them about where they were, and Jay and Carlos say they were "carpet jacked", which is something that does not usually happen in Auradon. They were getting ready to head out when their carpet was literally pulled out from under them, but never saw who did it.
Just then, Jay and everyone else spot's Jane's mascot walking by. At first, everyone thinks it is Jane inside until she walks up to them. As everyone begins to wonder who was in the armor, the lights suddenly go out for a brief moment. When they come back on Ben has disappeared. The girls, especially Mal, look around the party but cannot find him. They come to a stop and think over how this could have happened. Pretty soon, Ally, Audrey, and Jordan start accusing Mal for Ben's disappearance. They think she is plotting something evil against Auradon, and making Ben disappear was part of it. This upsets Mal, and reminds them again that she is good now, when suddenly a girl known as CJ, daughter of Captain Hook, swings out of nowhere and onto the stage.
- Dove Cameron as Mal
- Sofia Carson as Evie
- Sarah Jeffery as Audrey
- Brenda D'Amico as Jane
- Ursula Taherian as Jordan
- Jennifer Veal as Ally
- Dianne Doan as Lonnie
- Mitchell Hope as Ben
- Booboo Stewart as Jay
- Cameron Boyce as Carlos De Vil
- Myrna Velasco as CJ Hook
- Despite making cameo appearances in previous episodes, CJ makes her official debut appearance in this episode.
- It is revealed that Ben gets Jordan and Jay mixed up. (Humorously, Jordan doesn't know her name is typically supposed to be given to boys - Jordan: He's Jay; I'm Jordan. How many boys named Jordan do you know? Ben: Uh...)
- Jane comes out of nowhere and from behind Audrey, yet she does not see the knight suit
- Lonnie breaks the fourth wall when she rim shots Carlos.
- Jordan did not glow when the lights went out, despite having a neon costume on.
- Minus Jane and Lonnie, the AK girls accuse Mal of making Ben vanish; even Mal was surprised that they would accuse her of doing that given that Ben's her boyfriend and that she even turned Maleficent into a gecko to save Auradon.