Jay and Ice are first seen stealing Max's shoes when Max says he does not have cash or bud for them. Jay is later seen stealing candy from trick-or-treaters with Ice when they encounter Max once again. This time, they ask him about his costume which happens to be a "Little Leaguer" as referred by Max's sister, Dani. The bullies then try to force Dani to pay a toll in order to pass them, but Max steps in by giving them his candy. Later at 3:00 a.m., the bullies are trying to think of some other activity to do (due to most of the Halloween activities having ended at this hour) when they encounterThe Sanderson Sisters, who abduct the two bullies and lock them up in cages from the ceiling in their cottage in response to Jay referring the sisters as "ugly chicks", which offends them, with Sarah tormenting Jay by spinning his cage, causing him to feel sick. Later, when Max and Allison arrive to rescue Dani, whom the witches have abducted, the bullies beg to be saved, to which Max responds by taking back his shoes from Ice and leaving them in their cages as payback for their bullying. After the Sanderson Sisters disappear off the face of the earth at dawn, both Jay and Ice, still in their cages, are singing songs including "Row, Row, Row Your Boat" to fill in time before any citizen of Salem will find and release them from their imprisonment.