Marina and Stormy come to Pirate Island to talk to Jake and his crew. Stormy explains to them that she found a Map to Neptune's Trident. It is on a mountain that is in the desert. Mermaids can't walk on land but only a mermaid can touch Neptune's Trident. Izzy was once an honorary mermaid so she can touch the Trident and walk on land. Jake and his crew set out to find the Trident with the two mermaids. They get to Neverland and sail trough Sandbar Straits with the help of Marina and Stormy. Captain Hook sees them and finds that they are looking for the Trident.
He wants the Trident and he says that he is going to take it but the Jolly Roger gets stuck in the sandbar so he has to use a rowboat. Jake and his crew have to use a rowboat because of the thin canal but the current is too strong for them so they need Marina and Stormy to help them. Finally Jake and his crew reach the mountain and find the Trident. Then Captain Hook tries to steal the Trident but since he isn't a mermaid he can't touch it. Izzy however grabs the Trident and gives it to Marina and Stormy. The crew return to Pirate Island where they find a box from Marina and Stormy. The crew find that it is Izzy's Trident that is just a smaller size of Neptune's Trident.
- Jake and his crew collect eight gold doubloons.
- Colin Ford as Jake
- Madison Pettis as Izzy
- Jonathan Morgan Heit as Cubby
- David Arquette as Skully
- Corey Burton as Captain Hook
- Jeff Bennett as Mr. Smee
- Loren Hoskins as Sharky
- Jeff Bennett (speaking)/Kevin Hendrickson (singing) as Bones
- Ariel Winter as Marina
- Allisyn Ashley Arm as Stormy