On Halloween, the Gargoyles go out into public while Xanatos proposes to Fox, giving her the Eye of Odin as a wedding gift. The gift's magical properties come to light during the full moon, and she becomes a werewolf-like creature that threatens both Xanatos and the general population. Goliath is forced to help Xanatos and realizes that even he is capable of true love.
- Elisa wears Belle's dress from Beauty and the Beast in this episode.
- This starts a theme of her dressing up as Disney Princesses.
- Brooklyn, Broadway and Lexington are revealed to be aware of Goliath and Elisa's romantic feelings for each other.